Two Stockpile Reports Disagree. Compare the Base Before Ranking the Sensors
A LiDAR report and a photogrammetry report can produce different quantities without the sensor label alone explaining why. Before selecting the preferred number, establish whether both reports measured the same pile, at the same time, above the same base. Then keep the volume comparison separate from any conversion to mass.
The base is part of the measurement
PIX4D’s volume documentation describes a volume between an acquired point cloud and a base surface defined by a boundary polygon. That is a helpful reminder that the calculation includes an assumed or defined lower surface. Ask how the base was established, whether it was observed or inferred and how an irregular underlying surface was treated. A polished rendering does not reveal that assumption by itself.
Make the two calculations comparable
Compare the survey dates, pile boundary and inclusion or exclusion of surrounding material. Request the surface or point-cloud basis and the treatment of gaps, vegetation or other unobserved areas. Identify any editing, filtering or interpolation that materially affects the selected volume. The aim is a clear comparison of inputs and limitations, not an instruction to force two outputs to agree. No single sensor should be assumed to win every site or coverage problem.
Volume and mass are separate quantities
A cubic-unit result describes volume. A mass estimate also needs a density value and its units; multiplying by a different density changes that estimate even if the geometric volume is identical. Record the density’s source and whether it was measured for the material or assumed for planning. Do not quietly compare a volume-only report with a mass estimate, or compare different mass units under the same informal label. No bulk density is prescribed here.
Request a reconciliation record, not only a replacement total
A useful explanation identifies which changed assumption or data difference accounts for the revision, retains the original report and states the intended reliance. If a commercial quantity decision needs another professional’s acceptance, make that responsibility explicit. NEDD’s quantity-support scope should identify what is included and what remains uncertain; the existence of a 3D model does not guarantee an inventory, payment or survey result.
Copyable worksheet
Use one row for each field. Mark unknown information clearly and retain the original records.
| Field | Your note |
|---|---|
| Capture date and pile boundary | ____________________ |
| Base surface source and assumptions | ____________________ |
| Model coverage and material edits | ____________________ |
| Volume units and density basis | ____________________ |
| Reconciliation, revision and intended reliance | ____________________ |
Worked example
Illustrative example: a fictional yard receives two quantity reports. The review finds that one uses a level base while the other uses a different base definition, and one total also includes a density conversion. The team compares like quantities before deciding whether further capture or independent review is needed.